In this post…
The rise of the Trump MAGA movement has illuminated a troubling aspect of modern masculinity. MAGA is characterized by a fixation on dominance, fear of societal change, and an obsession with being a “real man.” Rooted in outdated notions of individualism, power, and exclusion, this ideology prioritizes self-preservation over community well-being. However, Druidry and Paganism offer alternative paths forward. This is a path that redefines masculinity through service, connection to nature, and the strength to be found in diversity.
The MAGA Cultist Profile: Fear and Fragility Masquerading as Strength
MAGA culture thrives on fear—fear of losing power, fear of societal change, and fear of the “other.” This can easily be seen in how MAGAs respond to any difference of opinion. The rise of death threats against those who dare to challenge MAGA demonstrates the fear-based worldview. A “real man” doesn’t have to respond to challenges with threats of death or violence. Such angry responses indicate a high level of fear. This fear manifests in an obsession with projecting strength, often through aggression and exclusionary practices. The MAGA ideal of a “real man” is steeped in toxic masculinity. The “alpha male” of MAGA supposedly embodies rugged individualism, disdain for perceived weakness, and a hyper-focus on asserting dominance over others. All of this is what they claim to value while worshiping one of the weakest men ever to hold the office of president.
Their vision of manhood is intrinsically linked to authoritarianism. Their “strongman” archetype promises security through force and control, reinforcing a belief that the world is a hostile place requiring constant vigilance and conflict. It is a view focused on outward appearance rather than inner strength. Trump gives the outward appearance of an “alpha male” while having almost no inner strength whatsoever. Such a worldview inevitably leads to division, with adherents clinging to a zero-sum mentality of “every man for himself.”
Druid and Pagan Masculinity: Service, Balance, and the Wisdom of Nature
In stark contrast to MAGA’s divisive worldview, Druidry and Pagan traditions offer a model of masculinity rooted in community and harmony with nature. Pagan chiefs and Druids of old often embodied a leadership style centered on service and self-sacrifice for the greater good. In these traditions, the following characteristics of what it means to be a real man were and are taught:
- Community First: Pagan chiefs historically ensured that their tribes were fed before taking their own meals, reflecting their role as protectors and providers for the entire community. This selflessness starkly contrasts with the MAGA ideal of individual gain at all costs.
- Strength in Diversity: Ancient Druids observed that nature thrives on diversity, where every organism plays a vital role in maintaining balance. They welcomed different perspectives and talents, understanding that inclusivity strengthens societies rather than weakens them.
- Leadership Through Wisdom: Pagan leaders drew on the lessons of nature to make decisions that benefited the collective, not just a privileged few. This type of leadership emphasized responsibility, empathy, and long-term thinking—qualities often absent in today’s hyper-masculine narratives.
Nature’s Lesson: A Path Forward
One of the most profound teachings of Druidry and Paganism is the interconnectedness of all things. Just as ecosystems rely on cooperation among diverse species to thrive, human societies flourish when they embrace collaboration and mutual respect rooted in respect for diversity and inclusion. This ancient wisdom is a much-needed antidote to the fear-driven, isolationist mindset perpetuated by MAGA culture in modern times.
- Collaboration Over Conflict: Druidic principles teach that strength lies in working together rather than competing against one another. In today’s world, this means cultivating alliances across cultural, political, and ideological divides.
- Embracing Differences: Paganism celebrates diversity, recognizing that every individual brings unique value to the community. By embracing differences rather than fearing them, we can build societies that are resilient, innovative, and compassionate.
- A Return to Service: True masculinity is not about domination but about service to others. Men in Pagan communities can reclaim their role as protectors and stewards rather than oppressors by adopting a leadership style that prioritizes the well-being of all.
Druidry and Paganism as Guides for Modern Masculinity
As we face a coming era of division and ecological crisis, Druidry and Paganism provide a roadmap for redefining what it means to be a “real man.” Instead of clinging to outdated ideals of rugged individualism and exclusion, these ancient traditions encourage us to:
- Rebuild Community: Invest in relationships and communal well-being. Leadership should mean uplifting others, not stepping on them to reach the top. What we do to others, we do to ourselves. When we develop deep connections with our communities, we ultimately benefit ourselves as well.
- Learn from Nature: Observe and emulate the interconnectedness and balance found in the natural world. This perspective fosters respect for diversity and sustainable living. Nature is rich in diversity. The less diverse an ecosystem is, the more vulnerable and weak it is. All humans have something to offer to a community. When we open our eyes to the lessons nature teaches, we learn to value, respect, and integrate that diversity to strengthen our communities.
- Practice Humility: True strength lies in humility and service. Leaders who prioritize the needs of the many over the few set an example of compassionate masculinity. It is an ideology based on love and respect rather than fear and division.
Conclusion: Choosing Connection Over Fear
The MAGA ideal of masculinity, driven by fear and isolation, offers a dead-end path for humanity. In contrast, Druidry and Paganism illuminate a future where masculinity is reimagined as a force for unity, service, and ecological harmony. By rejecting the spirit of “every man for himself” and embracing our shared humanity, we can build a world where strength is defined not by domination, but by our ability to protect, nurture, and collaborate.
In this new vision of masculinity, there is no place for fear—only respect, courage, and the wisdom to see that our differences are not threats but gifts. Through the ancient teachings of Druids and Pagans, we can chart a path toward a future where every man, woman, and child thrives together.
Share Your Thoughts on MAGA!
What does it mean to be a “real man” in modern society? What is the best path forward and what role does Paganism play in building a better future? Share your thoughts in the comments below!